Some ideas to promote new army compositions

Status
Not open for further replies.

Riku

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
43
I love the recent changes that were introduced into this game, especially munitions like the one that gives protection to defenders and make them relevant on the battlefield.
Even though, attacking has become a bit difficult and I feel I need more troops on the offensive side of the battlefield to run new army compositions. So, I would like to go further and suggest some balance rework:

1. Increase army troop space by 5 on each barrack at cold war age or further and/or reduce troop space of some selected and unused units.
The new university research on tactical helicopter is a good idea but it's not enough because this unit still needs 12 troop space, which is a lot.

2. Improve unused troops such as assault vehicle, medium tank, MRL, etc.
-Assault vehicle needs more hitpoints.
-Medium tank needs more damage or changing favourite target to "buildings".
-MRL needs more range, supression or something.
...

3. Rework attacking speed perk from mongols coalition to artillery and mortars. Nowadays it's the best strategy for wars because of this tactic, and it feels weird to see an artillery firing like a machine gun. So I think you could reduce the maximum attacking speed bonus from 76% to 25% and add a +50% projectiles blast area. This way artillery would damage enemy troops that are close to buildings.


What do you think?
 

Seek

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
684
I love the recent changes that were introduced into this game, especially munitions like the one that gives protection to defenders and make them relevant on the battlefield.
Even though, attacking has become a bit difficult and I feel I need more troops on the offensive side of the battlefield to run new army compositions. So, I would like to go further and suggest some balance rework:

1. Increase army troop space by 5 on each barrack at cold war age or further and/or reduce troop space of some selected and unused units.
The new university research on tactical helicopter is a good idea but it's not enough because this unit still needs 12 troop space, which is a lot.

2. Improve unused troops such as assault vehicle, medium tank, MRL, etc.
-Assault vehicle needs more hitpoints.
-Medium tank needs more damage or changing favourite target to "buildings".
-MRL needs more range, supression or something.
...

3. Rework attacking speed perk from mongols coalition to artillery and mortars. Nowadays it's the best strategy for wars because of this tactic, and it feels weird to see an artillery firing like a machine gun. So I think you could reduce the maximum attacking speed bonus from 76% to 25% and add a +50% projectiles blast area. This way artillery would damage enemy troops that are close to buildings.


What do you think?
I would agree with most this as a defender but something has to be done about FSH and Hangers they are just pay to win and throw entire balance of game to the Offense side .
 

King Crimson

Approved user
Joined
Apr 21, 2016
Messages
1,365
MRL needs more range, supression or something.
Actually I've just gotten used to a new combo with MRLs so they are actually quite effective (and fun) WITH the right combo supporting it.
add a +50% projectiles blast area. This way artillery would damage enemy troops that are close to buildings.
The aforementioned MRLs have a reasonable area of effect so not sure we need to turn the artillery into another MRL - but I agree the speed boost from Mongols is ridiculous. That's precisely why everyone uses it with arty/morty
 

Seek

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
684
Actually I've just gotten used to a new combo with MRLs so they are actually quite effective (and fun) WITH the right combo supporting it.

The aforementioned MRLs have a reasonable area of effect so not sure we need to turn the artillery into another MRL - but I agree the speed boost from Mongols is ridiculous. That's precisely why everyone uses it with arty/morty
MRL in their current forum are great for MP battles and low auto age O players Bases only if you hit 3D War Base they will get smoked. No matter what ur supporting them with.
 

witCat

Approved user
Joined
Sep 15, 2018
Messages
105
I would agree with most this as a defender but something has to be done about FSH and Hangers they are just pay to win and throw entire balance of game to the Offense side .
I have asked the question about FSH before but neither @Harlems369th or @TheWise or any community member answered it. I will ask it again, where does everyone get there Fortified strongholds from as it hasn't been on sale for more than a month? Can players make a request in the from of a private sale from BHG?
 

Riku

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
43
Actually I've just gotten used to a new combo with MRLs so they are actually quite effective (and fun) WITH the right combo supporting it.

The aforementioned MRLs have a reasonable area of effect so not sure we need to turn the artillery into another MRL - but I agree the speed boost from Mongols is ridiculous. That's precisely why everyone uses it with arty/morty
Indeed, I tried MRLs and it feels you need to invest a lot to make them ok. I mean, other troops like artillery, infantry just do their job and do it well as intended without a focused museum.
I may try again when I'm information but I'm space and I feel artillery is way better.
 

King Crimson

Approved user
Joined
Apr 21, 2016
Messages
1,365
Indeed, I tried MRLs and it feels you need to invest a lot to make them ok.
The same could be said for any worthwhile troop. At least, this is how it should be as you get to the 'good' ages - Info and above. No troop should be set-and-forget.
 

witCat

Approved user
Joined
Sep 15, 2018
Messages
105
Smells like external server
I can name many players who over the course of this month used at least 3 or 4 fortified strongholds. This should not be hard for BGH to track or is it?
 

Seek

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
684
Damm everybody that hits me uses FSH and Hangers lol they stocked up I guess or cheating somehow.
 

Rafar

Newbie in DomiNations
Joined
Apr 26, 2021
Messages
384
Yes, it's working. And now I found out (about 2 months ago) that it's possible to scan the map and reveal all the traps. And it's interesting to see some players attacking defensive bases without anyone doing a previous Scout and manipulating their game by escaping the traps. In addition to the already known resources for obtaining troops, buildings and manipulating troop strength. In fact, several cheaters think they're so amazing that they post videos of their attacks on YouTube as if they were just skilled and not cheaters.

Finally, it's still possible to play with an unlimited number of air troops using an exploit. If you want, you can play with 10 Tupolevs, 20 Recons, 40 Nighthawks and it's all good, after all, the replay doesn't work and you won't be able to prove that the player used more troops than allowed.
 

Rafar

Newbie in DomiNations
Joined
Apr 26, 2021
Messages
384
And I apologize to the creator of the topic for having crossed his post with something that is not relevant. I only responded because of the direction others gave to the conversation.
 

Rafar

Newbie in DomiNations
Joined
Apr 26, 2021
Messages
384
Ultimately, no! I will not be submitting any MORE tickets to CS about this. It never did any good and I have learned that I should not waste my time and sanity on this. It is not worth it.
 

Seek

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
684
Yes, it's working. And now I found out (about 2 months ago) that it's possible to scan the map and reveal all the traps. And it's interesting to see some players attacking defensive bases without anyone doing a previous Scout and manipulating their game by escaping the traps. In addition to the already known resources for obtaining troops, buildings and manipulating troop strength. In fact, several cheaters think they're so amazing that they post videos of their attacks on YouTube as if they were just skilled and not cheaters.

Finally, it's still possible to play with an unlimited number of air troops using an exploit. If you want, you can play with 10 Tupolevs, 20 Recons, 40 Nighthawks and it's all good, after all, the replay doesn't work and you won't be able to prove that the player used more troops than allowed.
This why I been continuously posting for Proof I know cheating is happening and game is dying cause of it. People like myself and many more know they can’t even tell what hit your base in War lol if you ask CS they can’t provide it cause there is none. This totally allows the cheaters to keep on cheating.

Well if the cheating was stopped replays fixed and proof of what hit a War was provided than profits would go up. Till proof of what was used is provided to the cheating will continue unchecked .

Stop telling us patience and fix the crap already. Your game is broke BHG
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7890.jpeg
    IMG_7890.jpeg
    2.6 MB · Views: 29

oddin

Approved user
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
1,771
Yes, it's working. And now I found out (about 2 months ago) that it's possible to scan the map and reveal all the traps. And it's interesting to see some players attacking defensive bases without anyone doing a previous Scout and manipulating their game by escaping the traps. In addition to the already known resources for obtaining troops, buildings and manipulating troop strength. In fact, several cheaters think they're so amazing that they post videos of their attacks on YouTube as if they were just skilled and not cheaters.

Finally, it's still possible to play with an unlimited number of air troops using an exploit. If you want, you can play with 10 Tupolevs, 20 Recons, 40 Nighthawks and it's all good, after all, the replay doesn't work and you won't be able to prove that the player used more troops than allowed.
damn... it is getting worse then!
 

Vapula

Active member
Joined
Oct 17, 2022
Messages
57
Yes, it's working. And now I found out (about 2 months ago) that it's possible to scan the map and reveal all the traps. And it's interesting to see some players attacking defensive bases without anyone doing a previous Scout and manipulating their game by escaping the traps.

If things have gone this bad, it's time as a community we stand together.. absolutely don't post it to cs, they were useless before and ever since the "revamp" and ltg Collab they have been even more dog💩

But what has worked in the past was exposing everything to the general public!
The forest clearing bug was fixed only because multiple people made posts and videos regarding the same, the Ares bot ban only happened because everyone posted and made videos about it, same thing happened with some external servers that were permanently banned..


If you know how it works, make a post going over it, and all the creators and players who are active on different forums let's all unite and spread it like wildfire.. (ps: if you are afraid about a potential ban I have lost all interest in the game anyways and am holding on by a hair strand, dm me and I'll make the post and videos going over it in detail and spread it. if I get banned, I get my closure and move on from this game forever, else we finally get BHG's attention)
Either they fix their game or everyone and their grandmothers starts exploiting... it's as simple of an ask as it can be
Because it's not fun playing and using IRL resources and $ when some jobless basement dwelling joe can simply pay 10-15$ or open and close the game 15 times in a certain way and get unlimited of everything
 
Last edited:

Rafar

Newbie in DomiNations
Joined
Apr 26, 2021
Messages
384
Guys, I've already sent countless tickets to CS always reporting cheating. I recorded videos, took hundreds of screenshots, detailed actions, cheaters and the means of cheating in words. For years, CS never showed any interest in knowing more. The same thing happened here on the forum. I made complaints, warned about bugs, exploits, external servers, apks and no one from BHG ever contacted me, even though I claimed to know how to perform some of the exploits. So I'm sorry, I won't share it with anyone. If BHG is interested, now they can contact me. And I'll think about whether I should help after so much disregard and humiliation in the way CS treats us.
 

Seek

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
684
We ask again for your patience lol after 9.5 years asking same question and for proof think all of us have showed enough patience lol
That is what I get told also after years of reporting to CS and that is from one I reported yesterday.

So have the guy or girl in charge of replays get his or her ass in here and take the heat instead of letting Harlem and The Wise take all the heat. Dude ant earned a paycheck yet in 9.5 years so pull him out of his moms basement and get in here tell us when crap will be fixed before entire game ends up quitting like I just saw two players quit yesterday alone that been playing years.

Or even better get the dam person in charge of entire game get in here
 
Last edited:

Harlems369th

BHG Community Manager
Staff member
Joined
May 6, 2022
Messages
1,006
Guys, I've already sent countless tickets to CS always reporting cheating. I recorded videos, took hundreds of screenshots, detailed actions, cheaters and the means of cheating in words. For years, CS never showed any interest in knowing more. The same thing happened here on the forum. I made complaints, warned about bugs, exploits, external servers, apks and no one from BHG ever contacted me, even though I claimed to know how to perform some of the exploits. So I'm sorry, I won't share it with anyone. If BHG is interested, now they can contact me. And I'll think about whether I should help after so much disregard and humiliation in the way CS treats us.
This isn't totally accurate. I did actually reach out to you requesting for more information, but you told me that you didn't have any additional information. You just claimed that you 'knew there was cheating', after you then gave me a list of potential cheating alliances which we investigated. We took action post the investigation, but as I said before in multiple spaces that you've been in, we cannot divulge exact details as to what actions. Players were banned, that is for certain, and we closed off points of vulnerability. I asked that the next time you run into someone you suspect of exploiting the game to report it, which you also then refused.

If contacting CS doesn't work, and us contacting you directly isn't satisfactory, how can I point people in the right direction to get this resolved for you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top