Battle Replays

Su_cre

New member
Joined
Mar 28, 2024
Messages
2
I find the replays from battles and medals gained or lost are not accurate. There seems to be a bug with displaying the actual events.
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
468
That has been reported for years.

Just like muse loadout still don’t worn
 

Harlems369th

BHG Community Manager
Staff member
Joined
May 6, 2022
Messages
818
That has been reported for years.

Just like muse loadout still don’t worn
After downloading 12.4 update are you still experiencing issues with Museum loadouts?

If that is the case PLEASE submit a ticket to the CS Team give as much detail as you can. I understand that it can be frustrating, but going through this process helps tremendously, this is by far the best way to help fix the issue each time you run into it.

I find the replays from battles and medals gained or lost are not accurate. There seems to be a bug with displaying the actual events.
There is ongoing work for the replay system, but finding a solution has been difficult. We'll update as soon as information is available.
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
468
After downloading 12.4 update are you still experiencing issues with Museum loadouts?

If that is the case PLEASE submit a ticket to the CS Team give as much detail as you can. I understand that it can be frustrating, but going through this process helps tremendously, this is by far the best way to help fix the issue each time you run into it.


There is ongoing work for the replay system, but finding a solution has been difficult. We'll update as soon as information is available.
Well you say work has been going no offense I personally have been asking for accurate replays for 8 years.
Now problem is not only replay system broke but past year or so the battle report is broke.

I suggested this in past and will suggest it again. Fix battle report first. If BHG can track every thing I spend on game then fixing battle report that ignores number of air strifes made by air unit ( herd that as excuse from cs for battle report being whacked)
Excuse I have been told by staff on replays and battle report over 8 years
1. Our phones can’t handle replays
2. Extra Strong Hold ( 29.95 one) cause misread of TT
3. It’s projected star count on war battle in replays not actual
4. That the AI system counts strifes made by air units as air troops and TT amount

I can continue list but what’s point lol

By not fixing this you make people think cheating is going on. Also get 1 or 2 stars in replay and then on war map it shows up 5 stars. This again make people think glitching is going on ie cheating.
 
Last edited:

Harlems369th

BHG Community Manager
Staff member
Joined
May 6, 2022
Messages
818
Well you say work has been going no offense I personally have been asking for accurate replays for 8 years.
Now problem is not only replay system broke but past year or so the battle report is broke.

I suggested this in past and will suggest it again. Fix battle report first. If BHG can track every thing I spend on game then fixing battle report that ignores number of air strifes made by air unit ( herd that as excuse from cs for battle report being whacked)
Excuse I have been told by staff on replays and battle report over 8 years
1. Our phones can’t handle replays
2. Extra Strong Hold ( 29.95 one) cause misread of TT
3. It’s projected star count on war battle in replays not actual
4. That the AI system counts strifes made by air units as air troops and TT amount

I can continue list but what’s point lol

By not fixing this you make people think cheating is going on. Also get 1 or 2 stars in replay and then on war map it shows up 5 stars. This again make people think glitching is going on ie cheating.
I get it, I really do, but please submit to CS. Dev team cannot help if they don't get information, if they don't get tickets, if they don't get detailed steps to reproduce an issue. I can't help you if you don't submit anything. I'm not saying it gets fixed today, or maybe even this month, but not reporting issues you run into doesn't get the help you're looking for.

Things may not be accurate in the replay system's current form, but I can say, and I know it doesn't mean much, work is being done.
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
468
I get it, I really do, but please submit to CS. Dev team cannot help if they don't get information, if they don't get tickets, if they don't get detailed steps to reproduce an issue. I can't help you if you don't submit anything. I'm not saying it gets fixed today, or maybe even this month, but not reporting issues you run into doesn't get the help you're looking for.

Things may not be accurate in the replay system's current form, but I can say, and I know it doesn't mean much, work is being done.
It’s been reported multiple times by multiple folks on load outs . Advantages of being in big alliance family 🤫
 

Harlems369th

BHG Community Manager
Staff member
Joined
May 6, 2022
Messages
818
It’s been reported multiple times by multiple folks on load outs . Advantages of being in big alliance family 🤫
If you're still experiencing issues with museum loadouts after updating to 12.4 please submit a report so the team can take a look, even if you've already submitted one previously.
 

kent irwin

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 24, 2019
Messages
23
After downloading 12.4 update are you still experiencing issues with Museum loadouts?

If that is the case PLEASE submit a ticket to the CS Team give as much detail as you can. I understand that it can be frustrating, but going through this process helps tremendously, this is by far the best way to help fix the issue each time you run into it.


There is ongoing work for the replay system, but finding a solution has been difficult. We'll update as soon as information is available.
Here's a suggestion. Put a bit more emphasis on fixing what's broken instead of adding more and more new stuff. Inaccurate battle replays are useless. The war matching system has been fubar for as long as I've played the game. Those are two real qol issues.
 

oddin

Approved user
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
1,625
The #1 priority should be to fix replays. Make them actual recordings.
And give us more stats about everything in WW. As of now, we know nothing .
 

nobodyknowsthetrouble

Approved user
Joined
Feb 28, 2018
Messages
167
Make them actual recordings.
ってどういう意味ですか?

私たちのデバイスはすでに容量の限界に達していることがよくあります。 特に戦争では、特に多数の防衛側と自国の軍隊が同時に展開されます。 このゲームは、すべての防御側が同時に出現して保護シンボルを受け取り、攻撃側が同時に派遣されてドイツ騎士団の激怒を受け取る、高速で動くスライドショーのようなものです。

現在のリソース節約バージョンのレプリカは良いアイデアだと思います。 保存する必要がある追加パラメータはいくつかだけです。 たとえば、森の守護者が現れる場所。 そしておそらく実際に活動している博物館、評議会、弾薬庫、そして国会議事堂。
 

oddin

Approved user
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
1,625
you keep posting messages in your language but i cannot read it. sorry
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
468
I have said the same thing repeatedly cause would like to see his side
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
468
Battle reports are accurate?

Then explain this According to battle report from our current war:
3 recons, 8 bombers, 2 Turps plus other ground TT being used.

This is a common battle report for the past year or so

I reported multiple times not even bothering with tickets anymore. So how about this being fixed finally.
 

nobodyknowsthetrouble

Approved user
Joined
Feb 28, 2018
Messages
167
原因と結果を混同しないでください。 そうしないと、開発者は間違った場所を探してしまい、問題を見つけることができなくなります。

あなたが言いたいのは「実際のレポート」ではなく、以前に見たリプレイの要約です。 リプレイで 12 機の爆撃機 (撃墜) が表示される場合、サマリーにも 12 機の爆撃機が表示されます。 これによって要約が不正確になることはありません。 それはまさに見るべきものを示しています。

森からの守備陣の位置が間違っている。 リプレイ自体が間違っています。異なるレベルの部隊の組み合わせが間違っています (例: 同盟国の「重戦車モデル 14」 3 台と、こちらの「重戦車モデル 10」の 7 台を合計すると、合計 10 個の「重戦車モデル 10」になります。)しかし、リプレイでは明らかに異なるレベルが見られました)。
最近誰かが示唆したように、パーセンテージも間違っている可能性があります。

本当に間違っているわけではありませんが、表現が不十分なのは、失われた軍隊だけが表示されることです。 生き残った部隊も見たほうが良いでしょう。
それが正されれば、最終的には当然そのまとめは正しいものになります。
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
468
I really wish I could read different language post. Cause I would love to read input from Nobodyknows . Be nice if was auto translated
 

Der BabyHund

Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2022
Messages
55
I really wish I could read different language post. Cause I would love to read input from Nobodyknows . Be nice if was auto translated
I told him before to run his posts through google translate before posting, or at least offer us some free Japanese lessons lol (I’m assuming it’s Japanese but I don’t have a clue).
 

King Crimson

Approved user
Joined
Apr 21, 2016
Messages
1,114
I told him before to run his posts through google translate before posting, or at least offer us some free Japanese lessons lol (I’m assuming it’s Japanese but I don’t have a clue).
Here's the translation I got from Google:
I would like to add USA or Russia to the game because they have better, more well rounded armies and would bring a much needed balance to the game. Furthermore, their rich culture and architecture would add a new dynamic to the gameplay aesthetics and give much needed invigoration to everyday battles and world wars.

Personally, I think he's got his posts mixed up.
 

Der BabyHund

Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2022
Messages
55
Here's the translation I got from Google:
I would like to add USA or Russia to the game because they have better, more well rounded armies and would bring a much needed balance to the game. Furthermore, their rich culture and architecture would add a new dynamic to the gameplay aesthetics and give much needed invigoration to everyday battles and world wars.

Personally, I think he's got his posts mixed up.
Thank you! I agree, he must have meant to post it to the other thread, but it’s nice to see more and more people wanting new nations.
 
Top