See war stats

ravi11523

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2023
Messages
59
I don’t know how to view my world war troop stats, it shows as the same but I know it isn’t as my war and main hall in my council and museum is very different. Is there a way to view my war troop stats?
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
464
It would be nice to see total stats listed that include all factors from coalitions muse counsel uni and alliance perks the ending stats instead of depending on third party calculators
 

ravi11523

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2023
Messages
59
It would be nice to see total stats listed that include all factors from coalitions muse counsel uni and alliance perks the ending stats instead of depending on third party calculators
Do you know any calculators for that?
 

Harlems369th

BHG Community Manager
Staff member
Joined
May 6, 2022
Messages
817
A place to review War stats, or just Alliance stats in general has been a regular request. Same for the Council and Coalition stats as mentioned above. I want to take the opportunity to use this thread to gather everyone's needs/asks if we were to implement this.

What information are you looking for specifically?
What Alliance information, War stats, is there specific information from previous Wars you're looking for?

Please let us know!
 

LuSt

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 29, 2020
Messages
181
A place to review War stats, or just Alliance stats in general has been a regular request. Same for the Council and Coalition stats as mentioned above. I want to take the opportunity to use this thread to gather everyone's needs/asks if we were to implement this.

What information are you looking for specifically?
What Alliance information, War stats, is there specific information from previous Wars you're looking for?

Please let us know!
I don’t think the focus is on stats of the alliance as a whole, but being requested that we are able to see stats of enemy bases with all the various forms of buffs to troops in the game consolidated into 1 simple to read page when viewing an enemies base during war.

(Also let us view our own teammates stats)

For example currently we can spy enemy museum, enemy library, and enemy university in 3 seperate tabs, but have no way to see their councilor buffs/debuffs or manufacturing buffs.

Why not just consolidate everything into 1 list? Let a player click on an enemy base and see that it has (for example) +227% fighter damage that is combined from all sources- museum, councilors, library, university, manufacturing, etc…

Next line would show fighter hit points, then defender spawn time, then enemy defender spawn time, then attack speed increase, so on and so forth.

1 simple, easy to read list.

(Plus fix the perk 23 drone issue that’s been a problem for over a month 😒)
 

Sega

Active member
Joined
Dec 5, 2023
Messages
226
A place to review War stats, or just Alliance stats in general has been a regular request. Same for the Council and Coalition stats as mentioned above. I want to take the opportunity to use this thread to gather everyone's needs/asks if we were to implement this.

What information are you looking for specifically?
What Alliance information, War stats, is there specific information from previous Wars you're looking for?

Please let us know!
Please then create a separate forum thread for a poll - the statistics in the game that players want to see. This topic has already been raised. Statistics on troops, Aliances, Wars, benefits received from the Concil, Museum, Library, University, Manufactory, etc., etc., etc. There are clearly not enough statistics in the game.

As far as I understand, this is also one of the long-awaited improvements to the game - various kinds of statistics.
 
Last edited:

nobodyknowsthetrouble

Approved user
Joined
Feb 28, 2018
Messages
166
同盟情報 (最優先事項ではない):
- 送受信した軍隊を均一にカウントします(戦争とチャットではユニットの評価が異なります)(長期バグ)
- 軍隊統計に類似: (生涯) 議会に研究ポイントを送信
- 部隊統計に類似: (生涯) スピードアップ要求に対する送受信されたヘルプ

(Also let us view our own teammates stats)
(y)
1 simple, easy to read list.
戦争関連の情報のみをお願いします。 相手がキャラバンからより多くの収入を得ているかどうかを知る必要はありません。
理想的には並べ替えられます。 部隊の種類によるいずれか (例: 戦闘機の HP と戦闘機のダメージが直接隣接している)
または攻撃側と防御側で並べ替えます。


私たち自身のユニットの概要も必要です。 現在、軍隊に関する情報を見ると、マルチプレイヤーと戦争を切り替えるオプションはありません。
 
Last edited:

Maxis

Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2023
Messages
45
A place to review War stats, or just Alliance stats in general has been a regular request. Same for the Council and Coalition stats as mentioned above. I want to take the opportunity to use this thread to gather everyone's needs/asks if we were to implement this.

What information are you looking for specifically?
What Alliance information, War stats, is there specific information from previous Wars you're looking for?

Please let us know!
One simple way is to split the ? Window in barracks/airstrip… after clicking on the desired troop. It shows HP, Dmg, damage against specific things for MP battles. The split window should show war stats (including coals …)
 

Gelonia

Approved user
Joined
Nov 19, 2018
Messages
168
Non so come visualizzare le statistiche delle mie truppe della guerra mondiale, sono le stesse, ma so che non è così perché la mia sala di guerra e la sala principale del mio consiglio e del museo sono molto diverse. C'è un modo per visualizzare le statistiche delle mie truppe di guerra?
Nel tuo pensiero.Forse devi cliccare nel museo ci sono icone di informazioni con percentuali.
 

ravi11523

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2023
Messages
59
A place to review War stats, or just Alliance stats in general has been a regular request. Same for the Council and Coalition stats as mentioned above. I want to take the opportunity to use this thread to gather everyone's needs/asks if we were to implement this.

What information are you looking for specifically?
What Alliance information, War stats, is there specific information from previous Wars you're looking for?

Please let us know!
Yeah a page to view all your buffs and bonuses would be nice. But what I am trying to look for is see my troop stats, as when I view stats in war, it is the same DPS and HP, although I have 3 coalitions and plenty of museum buffs for my troops, could it be updated so on the war screen the troops have their respective war statistics? Also a nice addon would be like war weight when viewing an alliance, or replay attacks from previous wars (some of the newer players in the alliance ask me for certain examples when I tell them ways to attack and I have some good attacks that could be shared, etc) Also, to have the ability to view enemy statistics in war with their respective buffs, like when attacking a strong enemy, I want to see the damage of some of their defenses. These would be nice to implement into the game
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
464
It won’t happen cause half stuff don’t work anyway lol
 

King Crimson

Approved user
Joined
Apr 21, 2016
Messages
1,109
I give my vote for a list to see our own stats. There's so many changes from the base stats over the years, from so many sources, it would good to view them in logical order from a single pov.

ps: viewing your opponents stats?? What's the point? Where's the challenge? Knowing all the variables before going to war is lame ... 😁
 

Seek

Active member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
464
I give my vote for a list to see our own stats. There's so many changes from the base stats over the years, from so many sources, it would good to view them in logical order from a single pov.

ps: viewing your opponents stats?? What's the point? Where's the challenge? Knowing all the variables before going to war is lame ... 😁
agreed only you and your alliance leaders can see in war total picture
I think it would be good tool for alliance leaders to have to know exactly where folks are at in development.

Get tiring posting muse council munitions etc in discord when if should be easy if your leader or council member of alliance for them click on your base and see everything. So complete war stats listed and complete view for alliance members if ya can’t trust them to see your in wrong alliance lol
 

oddin

Approved user
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
1,625
I don’t think the focus is on stats of the alliance as a whole, but being requested that we are able to see stats of enemy bases with all the various forms of buffs to troops in the game consolidated into 1 simple to read page when viewing an enemies base during war.

(Also let us view our own teammates stats)

For example currently we can spy enemy museum, enemy library, and enemy university in 3 seperate tabs, but have no way to see their councilor buffs/debuffs or manufacturing buffs.

Why not just consolidate everything into 1 list? Let a player click on an enemy base and see that it has (for example) +227% fighter damage that is combined from all sources- museum, councilors, library, university, manufacturing, etc…

Next line would show fighter hit points, then defender spawn time, then enemy defender spawn time, then attack speed increase, so on and so forth.

1 simple, easy to read list.

(Plus fix the perk 23 drone issue that’s been a problem for over a month 😒)
let me add to that, that we dont know as much info from our own team mates!! There should be a way for coleaders to see OUR spy screen!
 

nobodyknowsthetrouble

Approved user
Joined
Feb 28, 2018
Messages
166
let me add to that, that we dont know as much info from our own team mates!! There should be a way for coleaders to see OUR spy screen!
共同指導者だけでなく、戦争に参加するすべての人がすべてを見る必要がある
 

WileCoyote

New member
Joined
Jan 5, 2024
Messages
18
we should be cautious of subterfuge from new members joining from opposing clans to see ally war stats, therefore only Councillors or better should be able view ally stats.

A new leader in the Univ could unlock spying of Council or Manufactury.

Group/combine the stats from all buildings that can be spied onto a single screen.

Identify if there is a maximum that has been reached, e.g. -85% fighter hp.

Ensure that buffs/debuffs are applied in replays. I think this is partially responsible for inaccurate replays.
 

nobodyknowsthetrouble

Approved user
Joined
Feb 28, 2018
Messages
166
we should be cautious of subterfuge from new members joining from opposing clans to see ally war stats, therefore only Councillors or better should be able view ally stats.
この制限は私にとって意味がありません。
第一に、戦争参加者のみがデータを参照できる場合、ランク制限は必要ありません。
第二に、村や要塞が埋まっているかどうかを確認する際には、戦争参加者への制限がすでにうまく機能しています。
第三に、敵対者が自らのスパイ活動を通じてすべてを把握できるのであれば、同盟を変更する理由はありません。

Ensure that buffs/debuffs are applied in replays. I think this is partially responsible for inaccurate replays.
最大の間違いは、森の防衛者が別の場所にスポーンしたときに起こります。 その後、飛行機は間違った目標を探し、すべての部隊は戦闘時とは異なる行動をします。
ボーナスの計算が正しくないことも別の原因である可能性があります。 しかし、私はまだ証拠を見ていません。
 
Last edited:

WileCoyote

New member
Joined
Jan 5, 2024
Messages
18
この制限は私にとって意味がありません。
第一に、戦争参加者のみがデータを参照できる場合、ランク制限は必要ありません。
第二に、村や要塞が埋まっているかどうかを確認する際には、戦争参加者への制限がすでにうまく機能しています。
第三に、敵対者が自らのスパイ活動を通じてすべてを把握できるのであれば、同盟を変更する理由はありません。


最大の間違いは、森の防衛者が別の場所にスポーンしたときに起こります。 その後、飛行機は間違った目標を探し、すべての部隊は戦闘時とは異なる行動をします。
ボーナスの計算が正しくないことも別の原因である可能性があります。 しかし、私はまだ証拠を見ていません。
Enemies would only be able to see stats from buildings that can be spied. New members joining the enemy can see that as well, and it doesn't matter if they are in the war or not. I assumed that the reason ally stats have been hidden so long is because BHG was mitigating the risk of spies. My only intent is to caution this. New allies should not see everything.


I agree that forest defender spawn locations affect replays. I only suspect that it is additional stats that contribute to the other inaccurate replays. if you observe these inaccurate replays, it will often appear easier or tougher, in the broadest sense. The individual troop AI protocol seems to work just fine. There must be something affecting it, and the additional stats are a likely reason. I believe this is a result of how BHG stores replays, because they do it differently that other companies. I beleive replays are stored on your device and not on a server. Your device won't pull the other players stats. Just my guess.
 

nobodyknowsthetrouble

Approved user
Joined
Feb 28, 2018
Messages
166
New members joining the enemy can see that as well, and it doesn't matter if they are in the war or not.
しかし、まさにここが私たちの提案と異なる点です。
私は、例えば戦争中の軍隊への寄付などにすでに適用されている機能制限があると言いました。 これにより、「スパイ」を効果的に防止できます。
車輪を再発明する必要はありません。 この制限は、戦争中の建物統計などを表示するのにも適しています。

I beleive replays are stored on your device and not on a server
これらはおそらくデバイスに短期間保存されます。 ただし、もちろんサーバー上でも同様です。そうしないと、他の人のリプレイを見ることができなくなります。
 

Sega

Active member
Joined
Dec 5, 2023
Messages
226
Have you ever paid attention to the message “Sending results to the server”? It would be worth it. This just means that all results are stored on servers and then downloaded back at the request of the player for playback. What's the point of storing this on the player's device?
 
Top