Detachments - Great Feature

[witCat]

@Harlems369th Detachments are a fantastic addition, and the “Prepare for Battle” screen looks great while feeling fresh and engaging. However, there are a couple of things to consider:
1. The war screen feels cluttered. Removing the ‘Available loot’ box could help, as we already know what resources we’ll gain before the attack.
2. The Rally button should be moved back to its original position, leaving only the Detachment rallies on the right—hand side of the screen.
3. Detachments should have no troop limitations—players should be able to choose any troops they want for each detachment (A, B, and C), including those from the Mercenary Camp and TT’s.

 

[King Crimson]

I understood the function, but that doesn't solve the problem of overview.

That's exactly my point. Why do you want up to 12 grouped troop icons in the middle of the tray when the same function can also be displayed with 3 rally icons.

You know ... it's ok if people don't don't agree with you. You don't need to constantly try to convince people you're right.

 

[nobodyknowsthetrouble]

You know ... it's ok if people don't don't agree with you. You don't need to constantly try to convince people you're right.

Do you know that forums were created for discussion? I bring arguments for one point of view and ask for arguments for others.

If you want to make statements without hearing other opinions, then write to Support. Forums are there to debate.

 

[King Crimson]

Do you know that forums were created for discussion? I bring arguments for one point of view and ask for arguments for others.

If you want to make statements without hearing other opinions, then write to Support. Forums are there to debate.

You bring arguments and that's fine, but make your point & leave it at that - no need to keep going on & on if your argument is valid. You make your point 3 or 4 times then you just sound desperate.
Let others state their own opinion and leave it at that. (if you can)
And a public forum means l can can criticise you too. Sorry if it bothers you.

 

[nobodyknowsthetrouble]

And a public forum means l can can criticise you too.

And that's where you misunderstand a forum. Forums are not there to get personal. Ideas should be discussed. But if you don't have any valid counterarguments, you probably have no choice but to criticize people.

Let others state their own opinion

with reasons would be even better. Only if you understand what led someone else to their opinion, you will be able to find good compromises or suggestions for improvement that suit everyone. There are many examples; here is one from social media: https://www.instagram.com/coaching.karlamatar/reel/DFDuP4Rz4Vz/

So far, no one has argued that they actually want to see the troops. Only the new buttons on the right-hand side disrupt the overview.
Then a good compromise might be the following Tray: Rally, Rally A-C, Drone, Aircraft, Tactics, (Generals if not grouped), Mercenaries, (Troops if not grouped), Troop Tactics.
But it seems that no one is interested in a real suggestion for improvement. Apparently the main thing is to whine a bit. And even if we were to find a compromise, it is uncertain whether that BHG would improve the system at all.

 

[Helmsman]

I like that you can collapse the resources list, to bad the rally icons can't be collapsed to.

 

[King Crimson]

And that's where you misunderstand a forum. Forums are not there to get personal. Ideas should be discussed. But if you don't have any valid counterarguments, you probably have no choice but to criticize people.


with reasons would be even better. Only if you understand what led someone else to their opinion, you will be able to find good compromises or suggestions for improvement that suit everyone. There are many examples; here is one from social media: https://www.instagram.com/coaching.karlamatar/reel/DFDuP4Rz4Vz/

So far, no one has argued that they actually want to see the troops. Only the new buttons on the right-hand side disrupt the overview.
Then a good compromise might be the following Tray: Rally, Rally A-C, Drone, Aircraft, Tactics, (Generals if not grouped), Mercenaries, (Troops if not grouped), Troop Tactics.
But it seems that no one is interested in a real suggestion for improvement. Apparently the main thing is to whine a bit. And even if we were to find a compromise, it is uncertain whether that BHG would improve the system at all.

A criticism isn't necessarily personal - and to the surprise of no-one you did it again, stating why you're right.
Ok, you win.

ps: Let it go if you can - l will.